Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop offers a diverse menu centered around classic and innovative pizzas. Located in Penn Hills Township, PA, the restaurant provides quick, satisfying meals perfect for lunch or dinner. Experience their signature Greek pizza with white sauce, a local favorite, or try the buffalo chicken pizza enriched with bold flavors. The menu also features hearty hoagies, wings, garlic bread, and fresh salads. Prices stay friendly, ranging from $10 to $20, making it an accessible spot for families and neighbors. Open daily from 11 AM, the shop handles large orders efficiently, ensuring your party or family gathering is covered. Whether you crave a quick slice or a full meal, Carol of Caseys is your neighborhood destination for comfort food crafted with care.
Step inside Carol of Caseys, and you find a casual, quiet atmosphere perfect for relaxing meals or quick bites. The interior is simple yet welcoming, with wheelchair-accessible seating and parking, ensuring comfort for all guests. The aroma of freshly baked pizza fills the air, enhancing the laid-back vibe. Friendly staff greet you with smiles, ready to serve your favorites efficiently. Whether dining in or ordering for delivery, the ambiance encourages a community-oriented experience. The restaurant’s cleanliness and warm service complete the inviting setting. It’s a place where neighbors gather, kids find comfort in familiar tastes, and every slice feels personal. Perfect for family dinners or quick weekday lunches, Carol of Caseys combines quality, convenience, and community spirit in every visit.
At Carol of Caseys, pizza remains the star. Their Greek pizza with white sauce stands out, earning acclaim for its unique flavor and soft, chewy crust that even picky kids appreciate. The buffalo chicken pizza is a must-try, praised for its perfect balance of spice and creaminess. Besides pizza, they serve robust hoagies and wings, including options like garlic knots and provolone wedges. The menu caters to all tastes, offering Italian, veggie, grilled chicken, and Philly steak varieties. The shop's commitment to quality and affordability keeps locals returning. They handle catering for parties with ease, delivering hot, freshly prepared dishes that impress every time. The staff’s friendly service makes each visit a welcoming experience, fostering a true community feel.
Our mission is to serve delicious, high-quality pizza that brings joy to our community. We focus on freshness, speed, and customer satisfaction, ensuring every order exceeds expectations. Our specialties include Greek pizza with white sauce, buffalo chicken pizza, and large catering orders for celebrations. We aim to be more than just a pizza shop; we are a community hub where friends and families gather.
Our vision is to grow while maintaining our core values of integrity, affordability, and friendliness. We continuously innovate our menu and service to meet the evolving needs of Penn Hills residents. Committed to accessibility and diversity, we want everyone to enjoy our comfort food in a welcoming space or through seamless delivery. At Carol of Caseys, we believe that good food builds stronger communities—one slice at a time.